I recently heard about an experiment that began in 1927—and is still running. Started by Professor Thomas Parnell at the University of Queensland in Australia, the pitch drop experiment demonstrates something surprising: pitch may look solid, but it is a very viscous liquid that flows extremely slowly.
Pitch also has a long practical history. It was used to waterproof wooden ships and was often made from tree-derived materials. In the American colonies, particularly Georgia, North Carolina, and South Carolina, longleaf pine (Pinus palustris) was an important source of the pine tar processed into pitch.
By now, you may be wondering what any of this has to do with beekeeping. Hang on. I’m getting there.
A sticky connection
First, a quick quiz. Which of these materials do you recognize—and what connects them?
- Pitch
- Propolis
- Copal
- Amber
The connection is plant resin. Amber is ancient tree resin that has fossilized over millions of years, while copal is a less fully matured resin. And then there is my favorite beekeeping topic: propolis, the mixture of plant resins and wax that bees apply throughout their nests. That brings me from a nearly century-old experiment in Australia to a much smaller experiment in my own backyard.
My backyard experiment: Do grooves make a difference?
In March 2020, I used a Dremel tool to cut two side-by-side patches of shallow grooves into the interior of a hive box. For one patch, I used a ¼-inch router bit; for the other, a ⅛-inch bit. Between them, I left a strip of smooth wood. After harvesting honey that year, I photographed the inside of the box. I cropped the image to show 11 grooves of each width, along with the smooth strip separating the patches.
A reddish film of propolis appeared throughout the photographed area, but the groove edges had noticeably thicker deposits. To examine that pattern more closely, I used SimpleCV software to mark the areas of thick propolis.
Here is how the total identified thick-propolis area was distributed:
| Surface | Share of identified thick-propolis area |
|---|---|
| ¼-inch-wide grooves, on the left | 61.5% |
| Smooth wood between the patches | 0.5% |
| ⅛-inch-wide grooves, on the right | 38.0% |
Those percentages describe where the thick propolis appeared—not the percentage of each surface covered with it. This was a backyard observation, not a replicated experiment. Still, the pattern caught my attention: almost all the thick deposits I identified were associated with the grooved patches, especially their edges.It gave me another reason to pay attention to something I had once treated mainly as a nuisance.
What happens when breeders select for propolis?
Watching my own colonies, I’ve noticed that some bring in much more propolis than others. That raises an interesting question: how much of that difference is inherited?
While exploring the subject with Perplexity, I came across a paper with a particularly inviting title: Honey bee lines selected for high propolis production also have superior hygienic behavior and increased honey and pollen stores. D. Nicodemo and colleagues published it in Genetics and Molecular Research in 2013.
The researchers worked with Africanized honey bees in São Paulo State, Brazil. They screened 36 colonies and selected the three highest and three lowest propolis producers. Using artificial insemination, they then established 20 experimental colonies, divided equally among four breeding groups:
- High-propolis queens crossed with high-propolis drones
- Low-propolis queens crossed with low-propolis drones
- High-propolis queens crossed with low-propolis drones
- Low-propolis queens crossed with high-propolis drones
They waited 60 days before beginning measurements, allowing time for workers descended from the experimental queens to replace the existing workers.
More propolis—and some interesting company
The difference in propolis production was striking. The high × high colonies averaged 22.4 grams, compared with just 0.65 grams for the low × low colonies—roughly 34 times as much. The mixed crosses fell between those extremes, averaging 4.0–4.3 grams.
But propolis production wasn’t the only difference:
| Measure | What the researchers found |
|---|---|
| Hygienic behavior | High × high colonies removed 68% of experimentally killed brood within 24 hours and about 96% within 72 hours, outperforming the other groups. |
| Honey stores | High × high colonies had 49% more honey-covered comb area than low × low colonies. |
| Pollen stores | High × high colonies had 22% more pollen-covered comb area than low × low colonies. |
| Varroa infestation | No statistically significant differences among groups. |
| Brood area | No statistically significant differences among groups. |
Did propolis cause those benefits?
This is where the story needs a little restraint.
The study showed that bees bred for high propolis production also had other desirable traits. It did not establish that the extra propolis itself caused those traits. Because the researchers compared breeding lines rather than independently changing the amount of propolis in otherwise comparable colonies, the effects of propolis and the bees’ other inherited characteristics remained intertwined.
There are several possible explanations. Propolis might contribute to better nest conditions. The selected bees might also inherit traits that make them better at collecting food or removing dead brood. Both possibilities could play a part. For me, that makes the study interesting without making it a promise. High propolis production was associated with useful colony characteristics, but it was not demonstrated to be a shortcut to Varroa resistance or a guarantee of greater honey production.
Making peace with a sticky hive
My little grooved-box experiment and the Brazilian breeding study asked different questions. One looked at where bees deposited propolis; the other looked at what happened when researchers selected bees that collected more of it. Together, they have given me more to think about when I open a sticky hive.
In my own management, I’ve finally come around to leaving propolis in place rather than routinely scraping it away. I’m learning to appreciate the colonies that seem determined to coat everything.





